PSA Card Says Altered Baseball Cards Graded and Auctioned

A PSA graded and auctioned baseball card was found to have been altered. This is the first known instance of a PSA grading being negated by an alteration, highlighting just how important it is for collectors to be aware of potential alterations before they purchase their cards. Experts are also now considering increasing or decreasing grades on players with evidence that there may have been tampering during the playing days of these individuals.,

PSA grading is a service that grades and auctioned baseball cards.

PSA-Card-Says-Altered-Baseball-Cards-Graded-and-AuctionedA baseball card collector has filed a class action lawsuit against Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA), alleging that the appraisal firm intentionally graded changed cards and sold them at auctions.

Plaintiff Eric Savoy claims that he has submitted his own baseball cards to PSA for grading and has purchased graded cards from the business.

In reality, despite the fact that it was changed, he thinks he bought at least one graded card.

A card owner, according to the lawsuit, submits a card to PSA in order to get a rating for that card. The PSA will next evaluate whether or not a card is “genuine and undamaged.” If the firm decides the card is genuine, it will rate it on a scale of one to ten depending on its physical condition. If the business discovers that the card has been tampered with, it will not rate it on a scale of one to ten.


According to the plaintiff, the PSA grade will have a direct effect on the card’s market value, and a “step up” of one or two grades may raise a card’s worth tenfold, depending on the card’s value.

According to the PSA class action complaint, “contrary to its promises to customers, PSA rated a significant percentage of changed cards on its 1-10 scale.”

PSA knew the cards were tampered with, according to the lawsuit, when it assigned them ratings on a 1-10 scale. According to the lawsuit, the changed cards were subsequently sold with their newly inflated ratings, and The Washington Post reported in July 2019 that collectors had discovered $1.4 million in manipulated card sales.

In fact, according to the Washington Post, a Stan Musial card from 1952 sold for $2,800 in late 2017 and featured a spray black print mark on a white frame. According to the report, another 1952 Stan Musial card without that print mark sold for $28,100 seven months later. Collectors believe the two cards are the same artifact that was reportedly changed to eliminate the flaw, increasing its value.

Other changed cards, according to the class action complaint, had stains removed and creases smoothed out to enhance their value. The plaintiff claims that the cards are sometimes “trimmed” to create a space between the card and the edge of the case in which it was put. Furthermore, each card is said to have its own unique features, such as how the picture on the card is centered in the frame and patterns on the card’s fibers that accumulate dirt or other material. The lawsuit claims that changing these elements of the cards may result in a card receiving a higher grade than it merits.


According to the class action complaint, “Collectors were able to utilize PSA’s records to expose the plan,” but “PSA claims that it continued to evaluate changed cards without noting from its own records that it had previously rated those cards at a lower grade.”

According to the PSA class action complaint, the company’s pricing structure incentivizes it to over-grade cards for customers who are prepared to spend extra to have their cards evaluated.

The lawsuit claims that PSA costs are based on the perceived market worth of cards and that customers must self-appraise the value of their cards before submitting them.

PSA intentionally rated cards at higher grading levels for favored customers who submitted a large number of cards, according to the lawsuit, in order to receive the costs associated with such submissions.

According to the PSA class action complaint, the business promises customers that it would not grade changed cards and that if they do, they will be “made whole” for the value of the baseball card lost.


According to the class action complaint, the business deceived customers by grading cards that had been changed and then selling them to customers.

PWCC Marketplace LLC, another defendant in this case, is accused of intentionally selling changed cards that were claimed to be unmodified.

According to the PSA class action complaint, “collectors discovered instances in which PWCC sold PSA rated cards that were subsequently changed, submitted to PSA, graded at a higher level, and sold via PWCC by the original buyer.”

Individuals who utilized PSA’s services to rate cards, who acquired different cards that were still rated by PSA on its 1-10 scale, and who now possess different PSA rated cards, including, but not limited to, those purchased via PWCC, are all potential Class Members in this action.

Have you ever had your baseball cards valued? Please leave a remark in the box below.

Marcus J. Bradley, Kiley L. Grombacher, and Robert N. Fisher of Bradley/Grombacher LLP, as well as Sahag Majarian II of Law Offices of Sahag Majarian, are representing the plaintiff.

Eric Savoy v. Collector’s Universe, et al., Case No. 30-2020-01130892-CU-RI-CXC, is the PSA Altered Baseball Cards Class Action Lawsuit filed in the Superior Court for the State of California, County of Orange.

A “card trimming scandal” has been revealed by the PSA, which says that cards graded and auctioned may not be what they seem. This is a huge issue for collectors and anyone who buys collectible items.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does altered mean on a PSA graded card?

A: PSA graded cards are graded on a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the best. The letter after the grade tells you what exactly has been altered about that cards condition. For example, if it is an 8/8 PSA Card and says Altered, then one side of the back was removed or some text written on it by hand.

Can PSA graded cards be fake?

A: PSA cards are considered to be of the highest quality. They get graded by professional graders who use a stricter standard than most people would, so they can usually spot fake cards quite easily.

How can you tell if a baseball card is altered?

A: By looking at the back of it and noticing that there are no logos on the card.

Related Tags

  • psa authentic altered
  • psa fbi investigation
  • psa card grading
  • beckett grading
  • psa fbi investigation 2021